Connect with us

NBA petitions disciplinary panel over lawyer’s ‘Coconut Judge’ remark against Lifu

Published on

The Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) has petitioned the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC) over comments made by lawyer Kalu Kalu against a Federal High Court judge, Justice Peter Lifu, describing him as a “coconut judge”.


Kalu, who is associated with former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar and the African Democratic Congress (ADC), made the remark during an appearance on Channels Television’s Politics Today, where he criticised a recent judgment delivered by the judge.


He, however, withdrew the comment after the programme’s anchor, Seun Okinbaloye, challenged him to reconsider his choice of words.


The November 5 judgment nullified the leadership of the ADC led by David Mark, as well as actions taken under the leadership.


During the television interview, Kalu maintained that the ruling did not invalidate Atiku Abubakar’s presidential ambition or the nominations of other candidates contesting on the platform of the party.


He argued that the court only nullified decisions and actions taken by the Mark-led leadership from July 29, 2025, stressing that the judgment did not specifically invalidate the party’s candidates.


Reacting to the lawyer’s description of the judge, NBA President, Oyinkansola Badejo-Okusanya, said disagreement with a court decision should not be an excuse for attacking the personal integrity of a judicial officer.


In a statement issued on Friday, she stressed that lawyers remained free to scrutinise court judgments and challenge their reasoning but must do so within the limits of professional conduct.


“A lawyer’s disagreement with a judicial decision, however strongly held, cannot excuse personal abuse of the judge who delivered it. Neither the intensity of a political controversy nor the platform on which a lawyer speaks relieves that lawyer of professional responsibility,” the NBA president said.


“Lawyers have every right to examine judgments, challenge their reasoning and expose errors. Indeed, rigorous criticism contributes to the development of the law and the administration of justice.


“But personal insults do nothing to establish that a judgment is wrong. They offer the public no legal analysis and provide no remedy for an aggrieved litigant. Instead, they diminish the quality of public debate and bring our profession into disrepute.”


Badejo-Okusanya also referred to the Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners, 2023, which mandate members of the profession to uphold high ethical standards and accord courts the respect, dignity and honour they deserve.


She explained that the rules equally provide channels through which complaints against judicial officers can be formally presented to the appropriate authorities.


According to her, members of the legal profession appearing on public platforms have a responsibility to provide informed explanations of court decisions, including their legal implications and available remedies for dissatisfied parties.


“These obligations cannot be put aside when a lawyer steps into a television studio,” Badejo-Okusanya added.


“Our professional standing gives our words particular weight. Members of the public are entitled to expect that a lawyer discussing a judgment will help them understand the issues, the reasoning and the available remedies.


“That standing carries a responsibility to exercise judgment and restraint, especially when passions are high.”


The NBA president disclosed that she had submitted a formal petition, together with relevant footage of the television programme, to the LPDC for examination.


She, however, clarified that the submission of the petition did not amount to a determination that Kalu had committed professional misconduct.


“Mr Kalu Kalu will be entitled to respond. Whether professional misconduct has occurred and what sanction, if any, is appropriate will be matters for the Committee to determine,” she said.


“The Bar must be able to demand accountability from the Bench and insist on discipline within its own ranks. Our credibility depends on our willingness to do both.


“We can speak firmly, disagree profoundly and challenge judicial decisions with all the force that the law permits. But we must also remember that the manner in which we do so teaches the public something about the profession we represent.”


Meanwhile, the African Democratic Congress has faulted the NBA’s decision to petition Kalu, accusing the association of applying different standards in its handling of comments concerning judicial officers.


The opposition party questioned why the NBA had not expressed similar concerns over criticisms reportedly made by the Court of Appeal against Justice Lifu in an earlier case.


In a statement issued on Saturday, the ADC National Publicity Secretary, Bolaji Abdullahi, cautioned the legal body against allowing itself to become involved in what the party described as a political campaign against opposition figures.


Abdullahi maintained that the NBA should remain independent and avoid actions that could create the impression that it was taking sides in the country’s political disputes.


“The NBA is not a political party. It must, therefore, not be seen to be behaving like a member of a political coalition against the opposition,” Abdullahi said.


“What has Kalu Kalu said about Justice Peter Lifu that the court of appeal has not already said?


“We agree that lawyers must exercise restraint. But there is no respectful way to address evil, and the NBA cannot teach us one.”


The development has brought the NBA’s disciplinary intervention and the ADC’s allegations of selective treatment into the spotlight, with the LPDC expected to consider the petition and determine whether any professional misconduct was committed.